Accident Report: Fatal Incident During Waste Paper Unloading (English Translation)
At approximately 17:20 on December 11, 2017, a safety accident occurred during waste paper unloading at Dongguan Humen Zhanchang Paper Products Processing Factory, located in Baisha Community, Humen Town. The accident resulted in one fatality.
Background
On October 27, 2017, Dongguan Humen Zhanchang Paper Products Processing Factory began contacting Zhejiang Fuyang Tianpeng Mud Paper Factory via an online platform and communicated with Mr. He (telephone: xxx) of the supplier via WeChat to purchase waste paper. Introduced by a Zhejiang logistics company, truck driver
Xing Dun’an drove a truck (license plate:
Wan J40962, FAW Jiefang CA4250P66K2T3 semi-trailer tractor) to deliver the waste paper to the factory’s premises in Baisha Community, Humen Town, Dongguan City.
Payment for the goods was made to the supplier via WeChat by Dongguan Humen Zhanchang Paper Products Processing Factory. The factory also contacted driver Xing Dun’an via WeChat and transferred the freight fee to him after receiving the cargo.
On December 9, 2017, Li Zhanpeng (ID card: xxx), an employee of Dongguan Humen Zhanchang Paper Products Processing Factory, purchased another batch of waste paper weighing 30.56 tons from Zhejiang Fuyang Tianpeng Mud Paper Factory. He then contacted driver Xing Dun’an via WeChat to transport the cargo to Dongguan Humen Town.
At approximately 16:30 on December 11, driver Xing Dun’an’s truck arrived at the factory gate and reversed onto Fuxin Road in front of the entrance. Li Zhanpeng came out of the factory and instructed Xing Dun’an to reverse the truck inside the factory compound before unloading. Li Zhanpeng then told Xing Dun’an that he was going to meet a friend at a convenience store opposite the factory.
Accident Process
However, driver Xing Dun’an
disobeyed the instruction to unload inside the factory. Instead, he unloaded the cargo
alone and without on-site supervision, even though the load was visibly tilted.
As he removed the canvas and cut the binding ropes securing the cargo to the truck bed,
two bundles of waste paper from the middle side of the container fell from a height of approximately
2.7–3.5 meters above the ground. Each bundle weighed 490 kg. Surveillance footage from a nearby factory confirmed that one bundle struck Xing Dun’an on the head.
He collapsed immediately after being hit.
Upon hearing shouts that paper bundles had fallen and struck someone, Li Zhanpeng rushed to the scene. Finding the driver lying on the ground with two waste-paper bundles beside him, Li immediately called
120 (emergency medical services) and notified the factory owner, Li Dachang, who promptly arrived at the scene.
Personnel on-site also called
110 (police).
About 30 minutes later, an ambulance arrived. Despite on-site resuscitation efforts, medical personnel pronounced Xing Dun’an dead.
Victim Information
The accident caused one death.
Deceased: Xing Dun’an
Gender: Male
Ethnicity: Han
Date of birth: March 17, 1962
ID number: xxx
Permanent address: Chenjia Group 12, Dashan Village, Xianyu Town, Shitai County, Chizhou City, Anhui Province.
On-Site Investigation Findings
- Over-height loadingThe height of the waste-paper bundles reached 4.3 meters, violating Article 54 of the Regulation on the Implementation of the Road Traffic Safety Law of the People’s Republic of China (Decree No. 405 of the State Council):
“The loading of motor vehicles shall not exceed the approved loading capacity on the vehicle license. The length and width of the load shall not exceed the truck bed. Heavy and medium-duty trucks and semi-trailers shall not carry cargo exceeding 4 meters in height from the ground; vehicles carrying containers shall not exceed 4.2 meters...”
- Inadequate and improper securing
- The truck bed had 20 lashing points per side, but only 12 were used.
- The 12 ropes were fastened around the middle and top of the bundles. Proper practice requires securing the middle first, then the top.
- Heavy cargo should use wide special lashing straps, but only 6 mm plastic ropes were used, resulting in small contact area, poor restraint, and cargo center-of-gravity shift.
Liability Determination
- Driver Xing Dun’an: His truck was affiliated with Huangshan Yixian Qingshan Automobile Transport Team. He privately took transportation jobs via WeChat in his spare time with non-standard operations. He refused to unload inside the factory, ignored the obvious center-of-gravity shift, failed to eliminate hazards, and conducted risky unsupervised unloading. The falling bundles killed him. He shall be held responsible for the accident.
- Dongguan Humen Zhanchang Paper Products Processing Factory: The deceased was not an employee of the factory but an independent transport contractor who acted against instructions and performed risky, unsupervised work. The factory is not liable for the accident.